Benefit They're Real! Magnetic Mascara

248 reviews   3.5 out of 5
5 Star
(108)
4 Star
(35)
3 Star
(19)
2 Star
(40)
1 Star
(46)
Would recommend to a friend
  • great mascara, (Kellen1 GA)
    11/21/2022

    I will order again.goes on easy an ddoes not come off in clumps..

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful
  • Great, (Virganna LA)
    04/30/2022

    Real looks good on.

    2 out of 2 found this review helpful
  • Similar to Loreal, (gen22 LA)
    04/28/2022

    This is good mascara and doesn't smear easily. It isn't a miracle and I wouldn't pay full price for it, but on sale - its worth it. It very similar to L'Oreal mascara.

    0 out of 0 found this review helpful
  • Good, (Chickie565 WI)
    04/08/2022

    Covers lashes well and curls them up. Good Product

    0 out of 0 found this review helpful
  • Good, (11nina3 FL)
    10/26/2021

    I received this Mascara. It is good but frankly it is not that much better than Benefit Bad Gal Bang as for me, I do not see that big a different between the two. I use the Bad Gal Bang mascara over the Real Magnetic and this seems to work better.

    1 out of 2 found this review helpful
  • I have lashes!!!, (Ronniebee AZ)
    10/19/2021

    Yes, my wimpy eyelashes now are fuller and more prominent. I have only used a few times so the jury of my peers is still out. I think this is a winner. I left off one star due to difficulty removing, even when using cleanser.

    1 out of 2 found this review helpful
  • Fell for the Gimmick, (AQUAFINA TX)
    10/17/2021

    This is a good mascara on its own. I fell for the magnet gimmick. I dont see any difference in the way you apply it. I actually like Tarte mascara better. That one coates every eyelash, and you dont have to start at the base and wiggle up. If you want a good mascara, buy Tarte.

    0 out of 0 found this review helpful
  • Longer lashes!, (murphycuse NY)
    08/11/2021
    Person received free product as part of an internal program

    I have thin, barely noticeable lashes. This mascara made my lashes appear much longer-without leaving streaks on my glasses. It did take a few coats to achieve the maximum effects, but the application was easy. On the downside, I did think that my lashes looked clumpy. I also had some smudging under my eye. Overall, I think this is a good, not a great product. I was provided with a sample of this product in exchange for my honest opinion. The opinion is my own.

    20 out of 22 found this review helpful
  • benefit magnet mascara, (superice IN)
    08/11/2021
    Person received free product as part of an internal program

    I was excited to try the new mascara. It went on easily. I applied a couple coats and it stayed on all day, and it was hard to wash off at the end of the day. I did notice some darkness under my eyes throughout the day, but I blame it on myself rubbing my eyes on occasion. Overall, I'm happy with the product and would buy it again.

    4 out of 5 found this review helpful
  • Good Mascara , (SA12 WI)
    08/11/2021
    Person received free product as part of an internal program

    I liked this mascara. I have short, light eyelashes and the product gave me great length and the deep black color really made my eyelashes stand out. The handle on the wand made application very easy.

    4 out of 5 found this review helpful
  • Great for short lashes!, (mindysoo MI)
    08/11/2021
    Person received free product as part of an internal program

    I have very short, very sparse lashes (almost looks like I don't have any without mascara). I loved the design of this brush because most of them are too fat or the bristles are too long or thick and will smear product all over my eyelid. This brush's compact design made sure the product stayed just on the lash. The formula definitely lengthened my lashes but not unnaturally.

    6 out of 6 found this review helpful
  • Great mascara overall, ( GA)
    08/11/2021
    Person received free product as part of an internal program

    This mascara was great to use overall. It did a good job lengthening my lashes. And it held up all day long even in the heat.

    3 out of 4 found this review helpful
  • I Would Trade My Mascara for This One!!!, (LHousman MO)
    08/11/2021
    Person received free product as part of an internal program

    First, it stated that it had "magnet" magic to lengthen lashes to the "extreme"...I didn't really think it performed that well here, however, it went on very easily, without a lot of work or extra coats. The mascara lasted through the day, but did smudge some while sleeping. My usual mascara also smudges the inside of my glasses during the day, but this mascara never did! Big plus! Would use again.

    7 out of 8 found this review helpful
  • Of course they're real darling!, (spinner201412 AR)
    08/11/2021
    Person received free product as part of an internal program

    This one did surprise me a bit. Right out of the new tube, it seemed like a lot of mascara for me. I think the tube itself is too large and could be reduced to store it easier in purse or drawer. I thought it was a little hype when it says magnetically charged, but it does extend lashes. Removes easily W/ MU remover.

    3 out of 4 found this review helpful
  • Nice Everyday Mascara, (SimKim FL)
    08/11/2021
    Person received free product as part of an internal program

    I normally use a primer with all mascaras. I tried the Benefit Mascara with and without the primer and didn't notice much difference. The Mascara goes on very well and the brush separates and lengthens your lashes. It's an everyday length, not a nighttime falsie look. You can continue with additional coats. If you want to refresh your lashes later in the day, the Mascara does not go on as easily.

    5 out of 6 found this review helpful