Customer Pick
4.0 ( 1965 ) READ REVIEWS

Benefit They're Real! Mascara

Prices and the availability of FlexPay shown on the previously recorded video may not represent the current price options. Consult the product page for current price options.
Benefit Cosmetics They're Real! Mascara - AutoShip
FlexPay available
Benefit They're Real! Mascara - Jet Black Black
Benefit Cosmetics They're Real! Mascara - AutoShip Black

Next shipment will be charged $27.00 + Free s&h

Ways To Save

Product Description

Benefit "They're Real!" Mascara 
Yes, they're real! For lashes beyond belief, mascara helps lengthen, curl, volumize and temporary lift and separate the look of your lashes for gorgeous definition. The long-wearing formula dries glossy, and the custom-designed brush helps reveal lashes you never even knew you had. 
Shop all Benefit Cosmetics

About Auto-Ship®

Why you'll love Auto-Ship:
Set your own schedule.
Get automatic refills on your favorite products. Auto-Ship lets you set up regular deliveries every 30, 60, 90 or 120 days—or you can create a customized a schedule that works for you. (Some items have preset delivery dates that can't be adjusted.)
Update anytime.
After your first order has been placed, you can cancel or make changes anytime. Just call 1-800-284-3900 from 8am-1am ET or sign in at and use the Auto-Ship Manager.
Lock in your price.
Even better? Auto-Ship locks in your price—even if it’s a Today's Special. So you’ll never pay more. And you'll never run out of the things you love.
It’s the smartest way to get more of a good thing.




Benefit They're Real! Mascara
1965 reviews 4.0 out of 5

Review Breakdown

5 Star
60.36% 1186
4 Star
12.21% 240
3 Star
8.14% 160
2 Star
7.79% 153
1 Star
11.5% 226
Would recommend to a friend
  • MsLoy, TX


    This mascara felt gummy on my eyelashes and they didn't look any better than my old favorite mascara does; it's waterproof, less expensive and from my grocery store.

    Was this review helpful? 0 out of 0 found this review helpful
  • maria2168, NY

    Very pleased

    Out of all the mascaras Ive tried (a lot) this is my favorite. Ive tried several brands. Im very pleased with Benefit Theyre Real because wearing false eyelashes are beautiful but costly & time consuming. This mascara makes my lashes long & full. Not clumpy at all

    Was this review helpful? 0 out of 0 found this review helpful
  • natalie7, MI

    Well, I applied lightly to upper lashes--

    --and arrived home w/o raccoon eyes. That's a success--big success Perhaps I can add a bit more on Sunday for church attendance & see if I get home w/o it flaking, or granting me those racoon eyes that every brand to date. So far so good---but not really been put to the test.

    Was this review helpful? 0 out of 0 found this review helpful
  • LMK3, IL


    Was a little disappointed!But the mascara does go on nice just did not make my lashes look very long!

    Was this review helpful? 0 out of 0 found this review helpful
  • JoTarka, OH

    Love it! Love it! Love it!

    This is my all time fav!

    Was this review helpful? 0 out of 0 found this review helpful

About The Brand

Benefit Cosmetics

Look gorgeous from head to toe – and have fun doing it – with creative cosmetics from Benefit Cosmetics. Entertaining and innovative concepts create beauty products that deliver performance with attitude while providing a feel-good experience to all who wear them. Benefit Cosmetics brings a much-needed sense of humor to the world of cosmetics, causing women to laugh, grin and wear it!