Benefit Cosmetics Waterproof BADgal Eyeliner Pencil Duo

This eyelineri is my absolute favorite and I have tried most brands out there. The major plus.....stays put all day! Makes the nicest line and slides across lids so easily! I will never use another brand!!

This eyeliner past the major test! Living in Northern California, where our weather is warmer and plants and flowers are blooming early, in February and allergies normally kick in around this time, I find it difficult to find eyeliners that don't run or make my eyes irritated. This eyeliner stayed on all day, even though my eyes were itchy and watery all day, due to allergies. This eyeliner did NOT budge or run, due to watery eyes. It applies so smooth and is one of the best waterproof eyeliners I've tried. I'm a MAJOR beauty junkie and I reviewed several eyeliners over the years, and this one is at the top of the list, great performing eyeliners. I highly recommend. So happy with my purchase!

I'm not a big eyeliner gal because I am a fair blonde and don't like a heavily made up look. I also have deep set eyes and rarely wear anything but waterproof mascara and liner (if any). The A/C better be blasting or I 'll look like a raccoon in no time flat. This liner is amazing for two reasons. It will go on in a nice thin line close to my lashes so it people say that "I" look good, not "I like your eye makeup today." Big difference! Secondly, it doesn't budge until I take it odd with any cloth or remover meant for waterproof makeup. I like the little soft, blender thingy on the other end, too. I always smudge to lighten the effect if I use it under my eyes. Great product and a steal in the duo!!

This product is an ok pencil. Goes on smoothly but is very thick. It also will travel up on the eyelid when on a while and feels sticky.

I like the coverage and it does last. However, for this price a pencil sharpener should have been included. I dont like buying a product and having to purchase another product in order to use it.