4.6 ( 31 ) READ REVIEWS

Benefit Cosmetics Goof Proof Brow Pencil Shade 3.5

Prices and the availability of FlexPay shown on the previously recorded video may not represent the current price options. Consult the product page for current price options.
Benefit Cosmetics Goof Proof Brow Pencil Shade 3.5
Customer Pick
or 5 FlexPay of $5.00

This item is eligible for gift options.


Promotional Offers

  • New to HSN? $10 off your first order with code HSN2023.  See Details
  • ExtraFlex available when paying with the HSN Card, QCard® or Zulily credit card. Select the FlexPay option above and then select ExtraFlex. Credit terms apply. Learn More
Credit Card

HSN, QVC and Zulily credit card perks Apply online or call 1-800-695-1418.

Product Description

Benefit Cosmetics Goof Proof Brow Pencil Shade 3.5

What It Is
This super easy brow-filling and shaping pencil works for all ages and skin tones.

What You Get

  • .01 oz. Goof Proof Brow Pencil - Shade 3.5 Neutral Medium Brown

What It Does

  • Custom non-sharpen "goof proof" tip in a teardrop shape
  • Wide part of the tip is used for quick and easy filling
  • Tapered point is perfect for narrow parts of the brow, like the tail
  • Soft color and a glide-on formula for super easy brow filling
  • Built-in blending spoolie

Clinical Studies

An instrument test on 20 panelists who used Benefit Cosmetics Goof Proof Brow Pencil found that it was long wearing, up to 12 hours.

An instrument test on 22 panelists who used Benefit Cosmetics Goof Proof Brow Pencil found that it was water proof.

Consumer Perception Survey
A recent consumer perception survey of 109 participants who applied Benefit Cosmetics Goof Proof Brow Pencil 4 times daily for one week reported the following:
 - 97% agreed that brows looked full
 - 96% agreed that brows looked defined
 - 94% agreed that it delivered beautiful brows the first time they tried it
 - 93% agreed that it transformed the look of brows
 - 95% agreed that it was easy to fill and shape brows

Made in Japan
Shop all Benefit Cosmetics

Free Exchanges



Benefit Cosmetics Goof Proof Brow Pencil Shade 3.5
31 reviews 4.6 out of 5

Review Breakdown

5 Star
77.42% 24
4 Star
16.13% 5
3 Star
3.23% 1
2 Star
0% 0
1 Star
3.23% 1
Would recommend to a friend
  • 97Butterflies, GA

    Great BrowPencil

    Easy on and very nice coverage. I will order again.

    Was this review helpful? 0 out of 0 found this review helpful
  • OmaJack, CA

    So great!

    Tried many brow pencils to create a natural looking brow with few hairs left. Benefit is great. It is smooth going on and stays put. Choosing a color makes it customized for me. My new favorite.

    Was this review helpful? 0 out of 0 found this review helpful
  • Vanessa88, CA

    Better than Anastacia.

    I usually wear Anastacia brow pencil but I'd though I would give this brand a try since it was on sale. I found Benefit's brow pencil to be smooth when applied. Also, the Benefit brow pencil has a richer shade of brown tones not a flat brown. I wanted to compare the two shades, so I drew a small line from each brow pencil on a paper towel. That's how I noticed the shade difference. Benefit will be my new brow pencil from now on.

    Was this review helpful? 0 out of 0 found this review helpful
  • mahalPheebs26, CA

    She's a keeper!

    I have barely there eyebrows and this pencil helps out tremendously! It sticks to the hairs I have and fills in awesome! I've gone through so many of these, at least 6 pencils. And for someone who experiments with hair color - I'm ash blonde w/dark roots - I like the idea of having several shades to suit my needs. When I want a little hint of color or dare to go bold, I choose whichever shade fits my mood and hair color. It's the best of both worlds. This is a keeper for me!

    Was this review helpful? 4 out of 4 found this review helpful
  • shoesnboots, NJ

    Will not use any other

    Love it, my 2nd order, will not use any other eyebrow pencil.I use it to fill in, fill out and lengthen. I also love that it doesn't need to be sharpened. May be pricey but it lasts a long time.

    Was this review helpful? 1 out of 1 found this review helpful

About The Brand

Benefit Cosmetics

Look gorgeous from head to toe – and have fun doing it – with creative cosmetics from Benefit Cosmetics. Entertaining and innovative concepts create beauty products that deliver performance with attitude while providing a feel-good experience to all who wear them. Benefit Cosmetics brings a much-needed sense of humor to the world of cosmetics, causing women to laugh, grin and wear it!


When To Watch

Jun 3
10-11p ET
Summer Host Faves with Michelle
with Host Michelle Yarn
Add To Calendar
Jun 4
8-9a ET
Beautiful You with Tamara - Easy Summer...
with Host Tamara Hooks
Add To Calendar