Benefit Cosmetics Black Roller Liner Eyeliner

Glides on very nicely over shadows. Easy to work with. Omits a good amount of product. Doesn't bleed. Nice brown color

Disappointed with another product, I was hoping my eyeliner would stay on with this one liner. My eyes always water and the eyeliner never stays on and it doesnt with this product either.

The first few times I used this I was impressed. It came out as a nice deep brown and flowed out easily. This continued for about 8 applications and then it became diluted looking and difficult to apply. Disappointing. I thought I had finally found a good brown eyeliner pen.